Best Bourbon Whiskey to Buy Online in 2025
Our expert picks for the top bourbons you can order online right now.
What Makes a Great Bourbon
By law, bourbon must be made in the USA from a mash of at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak containers — everything else is distiller's choice, which is exactly why the category ranges from $28 everyday pours to six-figure collector releases. The best bottles balance sweetness, spice, fruit and oak rather than leaning hard on any single note, and the ranking below spans that whole range at real, in-stock prices.
The Top Bottles for 2025
Blanton's Original Single Barrel ($64.99, 46.5% ABV) remains the bottle most bourbon drinkers are actively hunting for — the original single barrel bourbon, hand-selected per bottle and topped with the iconic metal horse stopper, delivering rich caramel, orange peel and vanilla. Eagle Rare 10 Year ($37.99, 45% ABV) is arguably the best value in allocated bourbon anywhere — a genuine 10-year age statement with orange peel, herbs, honey and leather for under $40, when comparable age-stated bourbons routinely cost double. Buffalo Trace Bourbon ($28.99, 45% ABV) is the everyday-drinking anchor of the entire category — toffee, vanilla and dried fruit from the same Kentucky distillery that produces Eagle Rare, Blanton's and the Antique Collection.
Small Batch and Wheated Options
Four Roses Small Batch ($32.99, 45% ABV) takes a different approach entirely, blending multiple recipes for a lighter, fruitier profile with honey and pear notes that stand out against the caramel-forward Buffalo Trace lineup. For drinkers who want to see what higher proof does to bourbon without stepping up to allocated pricing, Weller Full Proof ($219.99, 57% ABV) and William Larue Weller Barrel Proof ($499.99, 62.4% ABV) both use the same wheated mash bill associated with Pappy Van Winkle, delivering honey, caramel and vanilla at genuinely undiluted cask strength.
Choosing the Right Bottle
If you're building a first bourbon shelf, start with Buffalo Trace and Four Roses Small Batch to understand the range between corn-forward and wheated styles. Once you know your preference, Eagle Rare and Blanton's are the natural upgrades for everyday drinking with more depth. The Weller cask-strength releases are worth seeking out specifically once you're ready for bourbon at full proof rather than the standard 40-46% ABV most brands bottle at.